Orchard Park Temporary Permission
Application type
Rural Workers Dwelling
Application status
Awaiting decision
Date of purchase
February 20, 2020
Date validated
August 4, 2021
Three temporary agricultural workers' dwellings for a period of 5 years and associated works inc agricultural barn with PV array to provide three affordable smallholdings to new entrants to ecological agriculture.
In August 2021 the Ecological Land Cooperative submitted a temporary planning application for Orchard Park. We applied for permission to create three ecological smallholdings. This includes low-impact dwellings for three households, as well as a shared barn with a PV array.
If successful, we will create a Section 106 agreement that legally ties each holding to operate a viable agricultural business. Assuming that after five years the businesses are successful we will apply for permanent permission. If achieved the farmers would be able to build permanent dwellings. The dwellings will conform to a set footprint and height, and will be built to strict environmental criteria. Under the Section 106 agreement these dwellings can only be occupied by households undertaking viable agricultural activity on the land.
The households would also be legally tied to an Ecological Management Plan and an annual monitoring process carried out by the ELC.
You can view the temporary planning application on the Cornwall planning portal. Resources relating to this application can be viewed in the right hand side bar.
For further information on elements of our temporary planning application please read below. We have summarised some commonly asked questions and concerns that come up during the planning process. If you are a local resident with a query or concern around a planning application please get in touch with us via email- info@ecologicalland.coop
Visual Impact and Development
We will ensure that any negative visual impact is minimised and screened where appropriate. Our existing sites prove that over the first few years the additional trees and shelterbelts we will plant will create a beneficial visual impact.
The location proposed for the barn and dwellings has been sited in one development zone to restrict sprawl, and to minimise any potential visual intrusion in the open landscape.
Given our climate, some covered growing in polytunnels is essential in this country to extend the growing season. However, we will not allow any of the holdings to become entirely covered growing areas. At present, vast amounts of food consumed in the UK is produced under plastic in semi-desert areas of Spain and Morocco, with the attendant problems of water shortages and near slavery work conditions. On balance we believe it is better for us to grow food here in the UK where we can monitor the production.
Any permanent dwellings will have to meet strict ecological building criteria. The dwellings would be moderate in size (not larger than 140m2 with a height limit of 5.5m) and in keeping with the landscape character. The ELC would also require the dwellings to be made predominantly of natural materials.
Any temporary accommodation will comply with planning requirements and will not be so large or high as to affect local landscape amenity. The most likely forms will be mobile homes or timber cabins. If needed we will require screening with natural materials.
Traffic & Access
We will consult with the council highways departments and ensure the access is suitable and safe for accessing the holdings. Additionally, we will create an off-road parking area for visitors to the site and prohibit parking on the roads.
The footpath crossing the site is permissive, and we welcome members of the public to use it. However, our understanding is that it’s official designation is around the edge of the field through the middle of it. It the future we will clearly mark the path around the edge of the field.
Protection of the Agriculture Tie / Section 106
The Ecological Land Cooperative is a member-led organisation whose members care passionately about ecological agriculture. Providing access for people to enter ecological agriculture is one of our core objectives, and our members would not allow us to deviate from this.
It is paramount that if the ELC is granted planning permission that the smallholdings are used for an ecological agricultural business. This means that dwellings will only be occupied by the person(s) operating the small farm business.
The agricultural tie is essential to seeing that the land is used productively and we will not seek to remove it unless there is another policy instrument that better protects the land. The ELC will always maintain the freehold of the land, which means it is impossible for any individual smallholder to remove the agricultural tie.
Management Plan
We offer a strict tenancy agreement to our smallholders. Just as with county farms, the farm business tenancy that we use allows the ELC to evict a smallholder if they are in breach of their tenancy agreement. The tenancy agreement requires smallholders to operate a viable farm business on their holding, and adhere to the site’s management plan.
The management plan places obligations on the smallholder. This includes agreements to manage the land ecologically, run a viable farm business, and follow all requirements of the planning agreements.
The ELC carry out annual monitoring to ensure tenants are following the management plan.
Sale of lease
Tenants cannot receive a windfall from their properties. If a tenant wishes to sell the lease to their holding, their tenancy agreement requires that it must be offered back to the ELC in the first instance.
In all cases the land must be sold at the re-sale value provided in the tenancy agreement, based on improvements the tenant has made. The re-sale of land is not based on the housing market and the ELC stipulates with a strict cap on resale value to maintain affordability for the next leaseholder. Tenants cannot sub-let, and any future tenants would still be governed by the lease and management plan.
There is provision in the lease for the tenant to retire from farming and continue to live on the land, as long as the land is being well looked after.
Financial Viability of Small Farms
In 2010 we commissioned research into the viability of ecological holdings on less than 10 acres. The report, Small is Successful, was published in 2011. This study of eight enterprises found smallholder annual wages to be in the range of £12,000 – £16,000 on established holdings.
In 2018 we conducted further research consisting of ten case studies of farms making a profit on small acreages from across the UK – with the highest level of income at £80,000 per acre. You can find the ‘Small Farm Profits’ report under the resources section of our website.
Our Values
The ELC’s creation of ecological small farms is not a money making endeavour. We are motivated by environmental issues, and concern for local economies and rural regeneration. The ELC sell 150 year leases on the land in order to recoup the money spent on buying the land and creating the smallholdings. The smallholding leases are sold at well below market rate to keep them affordable for new entrants to farming.
It would be against our values to conflict with existing local businesses. Instead we aim to provide a supply of local foods and products that are lacking in the local area, or where the demand outweighs current supply. We look to collaborate with existing businesses where possible and work together to improve provision of good local food for the local community.
Operations such as battery chicken, or other intensive livestock farming go against our ecological and ethical values. As such, these practices would not be permitted under our site management plan. The ELC monitors each plot against the management plan and reports to the council annually.
Example business from our other sites are vegetable box scheme, salad bags, cut flowers, sheep & pigs, herbs, micro goat dairy and fruit tree grafting.
The success of our endeavours will be measured by well managed businesses, increases in biodiversity and wildlife, and people contributing healthy produce for the local community
Application Process
You can read about our application process for potential ELC farmers here.
Our tenants go through a rigorous application process including an assessment of their business plans for financial viability.
Where all other things are equal and criteria are met, we will give weight to applications from people with pre-existing local connections over those from further away. As a cooperative we believe strongly in equality. Our recruitment process for new tenants looks at their passion and capability to build an ecological small farm business above all else.
Each holding must provide a minimum of one full-time-equivalent worker. Additionally, each holding may use volunteers or trainees as labour at certain times.
