Becoming a Charitable Community Benefit Society

Following a successful member consultation and positive responses via email from many members, the ELC board are excited to present the resolution at this year’s AGM to convert the ELC from a Community Benefit Society to a Charitable Community Benefit Society.

How we got here

Starting in July, we embarked on the journey set out in our new Business Plan, which was approved at the 2023 AGM, and have already made significant inroads into its implementation.

We are now the proud new owners of Ragmans Lane Farm in the Forest of Dean! Despite a lengthy and complicated conveyancing process, we finally signed the papers at the end of August. We are committed to supporting the existing land enterprises there and are eagerly looking toward future opportunities to develop.

This incredible donation marks a significant milestone towards fulfilling Priority 1 of our 2024-34 Business Plan: to acquire land and farms through donations as well as purchases. Ragmans Lane is our second donated farm, following Maesgwyn Isaf in Carmarthenshire in 2022. Both donations came with potential tax implications for both the donor and the ELC, so we decided to have the farms owned by our sister charity, the Ecological Land Trust (ELT), which then leases them to the ELC for management and subleasing to new entrant farmers.

While this setup has some advantages, a drawback is that the ELT is run by a small group of Trustees (some of whom are also on the board of the ELC) and so doesn’t benefit from the same level of community ownership and governance as the rest of the ELC land.

To explore how we streamline this process for future donations we successfully applied for funding from the Coops UK Business Support Package. With the expertise of governance specialists from Coops UK, we explored various options and are now excited to propose converting the ELC to a Charitable Community Benefit Society. This change would make both the ELC, and land donors exempt from tax on future farm donations.

This proposal also aligns with Priority 3 of our Business Plan: diversifying our fundraising efforts. Our recent consultation highlighted the charitable nature of much of our work and the need for increased fundraising to continue delivering these vital services. Becoming a charitable entity will not only help us attract more funding but also unlock tax benefits like Gift Aid.

Ecological Land and People Ltd

Due to legalities around the asset locks of Community Benefit Societies, it is not possible to directly convert a non-charitable CBS into a charitable one. Therefore, the way that this is achieved is by setting up a new charitable society and then transferring all the engagements (see below) from the existing organisation to the new one.

We have created a new society, which is charitable, with the legal name Ecological Land and People Ltd. It will trade as Ecological Land Cooperative and in this way, the business and functioning of the ELC will continue seamlessly.

We have worked extensively with the governance team at Coops UK to create the rules of the new society, incorporating each of the following:

  • anything that is specific to the current ELC rules.
  • anything that is required by society legislation.
  • anything that is required by charity law.

The new rules can be found here.

Transfer of Engagements

The ELC is registered as a society, under the Co-operative and Community Benefit Societies Act 2014 (the Act). This Act, which governs how the co-operative operates, provides for a unique way for societies to transfer, merge and amalgamate, not available to other legal forms such as companies. What is special about it is the fact that it allows for the continuity of the business and contractual arrangements without the need to stop, renegotiate everything and start again, making it a seamless process.

Co-operative societies have been doing transfers of engagements for decades as a way of
ensuring the strength and continuity of the co-operative movement.

The term ‘engagements’ refers to members, shareholding, obligations, liabilities and assets – in other words everything the ELC does and owns!

The Process

The process above is prescribed by the Act and has a number of stages.

  1. Meeting 1 – this is scheduled to be the AGM on 30th November. At this meeting, the membership will vote on the resolution to transfer the engagements to the new society. This is defined as a special resolution by the Act and so requires a majority of two thirds to be passed. Votes may be cast via proxy – details about how to vote in this manner will be shared in the official notice of the AGM due to be sent to members on 15th November.
  2. Meeting 2 – this must be held at least 14 days and no longer than 1 month after Meeting 1. The date is TBC but it will be online on an evening in December. The sole purpose of this meeting will be to confirm the resolution if it is approved at Meeting 1. This vote requires a simple majority to be passed.
  3. Providing the resolution is passed, within 14 days of Meeting 2, and provided all the conditions we need to satisfy to allow the transfer to go ahead are met, we will register the transfer with the FCA.
  4. Over the following months, we will aim to complete everything that needs to happen to allow the transfer of engagements to the new society. Including the bank account, lease agreements, insurance policies, land title registers etc.  In some cases, we need to obtain consents from third parties before the transfer can go ahead.
  5. We are aiming for the transfer to be complete by 30th June 2025 (the end of our financial year). Once the transfer has been registered by the FCA and everything has been transferred to the new society, we will submit a Section 126 form to formally close the old ELC. Before the transfer is registered with the FCA, both societies will effectively be trading in order to allow time for everything to be transferred.
  6. From 1st July 2025, everything will be transferred to the new Charitable CBS.

The Resolutions

The wording for the resolutions can be found here.

Questions

The form for submitting questions can be found here. All answers will be uploaded to the FAQ sheet found at the bottom of this webpage. Please check the document before submitting your question to check someone else hasn’t asked it already! If you have submitted a question please give us up to 3 working days to respond as we are a part-time team.

FAQs